Search

Bribery Case Against Chernivtsi Regional Council Head for Lease of Brusnytsia Sanatorium

  • The date of the first court decision within a pre-trial investigation: 19/02/2020
  • Instance: HACC
  • Stage of criminal proceedings: Pre-trial investigation
Track case progress If you would like to follow the case, leave your email and get updates sent straight to your inbox
Bribery Case Against Chernivtsi Regional Council Head for Lease of Brusnytsia Sanatorium Bribery Case Against Chernivtsi Regional Council Head for Lease of Brusnytsia Sanatorium

Case description

The High Anti-Corruption Court (HACC) has found Chernivtsi businessman Yurii Kushnir guilty of giving a bribe to Ivan Muntian, the head of the Chernivtsi Regional Council.

The bribe, amounting to $180,000, was given to facilitate the transfer of the property complex of the Brusnytsia sanatorium on lease to an enterprise controlled by Kushnir.

According to the investigation, the former head of the Chernivtsi Regional Council, Ivan Muntian, who is a regional council member and was elected as its head, asked a local entrepreneur, Kushnir, for a $400,000 bribe.

 

Picture

The money, according to the investigation, was intended to facilitate the lease of the Balneological Sanatorium Brusnytsia. The scheme was to secure the voting and decision-making by the Chernivtsi Regional Council to transfer the sanatorium for a long-term lease to a business entity controlled by Yurii Kushnir and to finalize the corresponding contract with him.

During a meeting, the head of the regional council specified the terms. He demanded $200,000 plus an additional 20% of future investments in the sanatorium, which he estimated at $1 million. This amounted to an additional $200,000.

Yurii Kushnir agreed to provide the illicit benefit, on the condition of further clarification of its amount and form. In the end, Kushnir handed over $180,000 to Muntian, which, at the National Bank of Ukraine (NBU) exchange rate as of October 15, 2019, was equal to UAH 4 million. This sum was to ensure the necessary vote in the regional council and the subsequent signing of a lease agreement with the company controlled by the entrepreneur. The investigation found that the money was transferred in tranches.

The HACC approved a plea bargain with Kushnir, who was found guilty under Part 4 of Article 369 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. Kushnir was sentenced to 6 years of imprisonment with a fine of UAH 83.26 million and a 2-year and 8-month ban on engaging in export-import activities. At the same time, the court exempted him from serving his sentence with a probationary period of 3 years.

Additionally, Kushnir is obligated to transfer UAH 10 million within a year to the Come Back Alive charitable foundation to support the army aviation of the Ukrainian Ground Forces. An additional UAH 5 million from the bail posted for him will be transferred to the needs of the Armed Forces.

Previously, the HACC had already approved an agreement with Kushnir in a case concerning abuses at the Chernivtsi customs office.

 

  • Proceeding No.: 52019000000000684
  • Case No.: 991/984/19, 991/1129/20, 991/1242/20, 991/1243/20, 991/1368/20, 991/2520/20, 991/2758/20, 991/3319/20, 991/1074/20, 991/4300/20, 991/4297/20, 991/6249/20, 991/6410/20, 991/8587/20, 991/7788/20, 991/10391/20, 991/1984/21, 991/2602/21, 991/4208/21, 991/6021/21, 991/361/25
  • Incriminated: Article 368, part 4, Article 369, part 4
Instance
The case is at the stage of pre-trial investigation

Infographics

THE CASE OF IVAN MUNTEAN

According to the investigation, businessman Kushnir gave a bribe to the head of the Chernivtsi Regional Council to facilitate the lease of the sanatorium.

  • pic
    July 23, 2019
    Ivan Muntian allegedly asked Yurii Kushnir for an illicit benefit
  • August 5, 2019
    The pre-trial investigation began
  • pic
    February 12, 2020
    An interimmeasure in the form of a UAH 5 million bail was applied to Kushnir
  • pic
    February 10, 2025
    The HACC found Kushnir guilty
  • March 18, 2025
    The HACC Appeals Chamber opened proceedings on a complaint by another defendant and his defense lawyer against the verdict
  • March 26, 2025
    The HACC Appeals Chamber upheld the verdict
  • pic
    May 28, 2025
    Cassation proceedings were opened

Decisions from the Register

Case No. Court Decision date Decision type
991/984/19 HACC AC 06/11/2019
991/984/19 HACC AC 06/11/2019
991/984/19 HACC AC 06/11/2019 Decision on partial granting of appeals
991/984/19 HACC AC 06/11/2019 Decision on partial granting of appeals
991/984/19 HACC AC 25/11/2019 Decision on partial granting of appeals
991/984/19 HACC AC 25/11/2019 Decision on partial granting of appeals
991/1129/20 HACC AC 17/02/2020
991/1129/20 HACC AC 17/02/2020
991/1242/20 HACC AC 19/02/2020 Completion of the preparation and appointment of the appeal hearing
991/1243/20 HACC AC 26/02/2020
991/1243/20 HACC AC 26/02/2020
991/1242/20 HACC AC 28/02/2020
991/1368/20 HACC AC 28/02/2020
991/1368/20 HACC AC 28/02/2020
991/1242/20 HACC AC 28/02/2020
991/2520/20 HACC 07/04/2020
991/2758/20 HACC AC 27/04/2020
991/2758/20 HACC AC 27/04/2020 Separate opinion of the HACC AC judge
991/2758/20 HACC AC 27/04/2020
991/3319/20 HACC AC 15/05/2020
991/1074/20 HACC AC 15/05/2020
991/1074/20 HACC AC 15/05/2020
991/3319/20 HACC AC 15/05/2020
991/4300/20 HACC 19/06/2020
991/3319/20 CCC 02/07/2020 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
991/4297/20 HACC AC 07/07/2020
991/4297/20 HACC AC 07/07/2020
991/6249/20 HACC AC 17/08/2020
991/6249/20 HACC AC 17/08/2020 Separate opinion of the HACC AC judge
991/6249/20 HACC AC 17/08/2020
991/6410/20 HACC AC 16/09/2020 On changing the interim measure
991/6410/20 HACC AC 16/09/2020 On changing the interim measure
991/8587/20 HACC AC 27/10/2020 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
991/7788/20 HACC AC 27/10/2020
991/7788/20 HACC AC 27/10/2020
991/8587/20 HACC AC 29/10/2020
991/8587/20 HACC AC 29/10/2020
991/10391/20 HACC AC 13/01/2021 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
991/10391/20 HACC AC 22/01/2021
991/10391/20 HACC AC 22/01/2021
991/1984/21 HACC AC 18/05/2021
991/1984/21 HACC AC 25/05/2021
991/1984/21 HACC AC 25/05/2021
991/2602/21 HACC AC 07/06/2021
991/2602/21 HACC AC 07/06/2021
991/4208/21 HACC AC 06/07/2021
991/4208/21 CCC 16/08/2021 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
991/6021/21 HACC 22/06/2022 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
991/6021/21 HACC 05/07/2023 Decision on the consideration of a recusal
991/6021/21 HACC 05/07/2023 Decision on the consideration of a recusal
991/6021/21 HACC 07/07/2023 Separate opinion of the HACC judge
991/361/25 HACC AC 18/03/2025 Opening of appeal proceedings
991/361/25 HACC AC 21/03/2025 Completion of the preparation and appointment of the appeal hearing
991/361/25 HACC AC 26/03/2025
991/361/25 HACC AC 26/03/2025
991/361/25 CCC 28/05/2025 On the opening of cassation proceedings
991/361/25 CCC 29/05/2025
991/361/25 CCC 24/09/2025

YouTube broadcasts of HACC hearings

More
YouTube broadcasts of HACC hearings